VideoEgg Declares Turf War on YouTube
VideoEgg, which has gotten more than a few press mentions today regarding the similarity of its overlaid video ad format to the one YouTube just launched, isn’t pulling any punches.
The San Francisco-based startup has redesigned its homepage to state “Welcome, YouTube. Seriously.” And then, for clarification: “We invented the video overlay ad about a year ago. We are delighted that the market is finally catcing on to a vital new approach to video advertising.”
Invented the overlay? I’m not quite sure that’s true. YouTube’s ads do look similar to VideoEgg’s, but then so do ScanScout’s and a number of other players. And it’s not like we can’t all imagine what would happen if CNN or the Home Shopping Network were clickable.
VideoEgg, which provides ad- and video-hosting services to a network of sites such as Bebo and Hi5, isn’t a consumer-facing company, so it’s not like many people are going to happen upon this declaration of war. But still, it’s pretty feisty.
Update: More detail comes from Epicenter, which links to the Apple-versus-IBM ad that inspired the taunt, and VideoEgg’s patent portfolio.
Sponsor Gallery
Recent
GigaOM Network
© 2008 The GigaOM Network. Powered by WordPress.com. Marketing consulting by ACS.
Vidavee developed interactive and rendered video ads in ‘05, with 8 issued patents (prior art in ’90’s) and new published patents (prior art in ‘05).
Thomas Gilley on August 22nd, 2007 at 2:32 pm - Permalink
Cute. Well, they got you to link to them, which was part of the plan, I’m sure.
Welcome to Every Sci-Fi Story Written Since 1985, VideoEgg.
Phil Nelson on August 22nd, 2007 at 4:23 pm - Permalink
Aren’t the documents referenced by the PTO link applications for patents and not granted patents? If so, it wouldn’t be a patent portfolio until approved and issued. Fly-over advertising is not new and existed well before VideoEgg or YouTube began business.
David Geller on August 22nd, 2007 at 6:40 pm - Permalink
I think it’s misleading that Videoegg claims to have “14 of the 20 top social networks” as a value proposition to advertisers. Their social ad network is so skewed; Bebo is 13-17 yr olds out of the UK. Hi5 is predominantly Portuguese. And Military.com?…that rules out the likes of Nestle, Apple, Unilever wanting to show ads on videos that depict tanks blowing up Iraqis. And trying to patent an”overlay” is like trying to patent the 468×60 banner.
Sabastien on August 22nd, 2007 at 10:11 pm - Permalink
[...] on it. There is way too much news on this front about the whole issue from Wired Epicenter, to NewTeeVee, and to round it out, CNet, Computer World, GigaOM, Techcrunch, Techdirt, and everyone else on the [...]
YouTube Users revolt over in video advertising | Streamaroo on August 23rd, 2007 at 8:03 am - Permalink
Video Egg (and everyone else who sells online video overlays) should genuinely welcome Youtube into the industry and be glad that they are adopting the overlay unit. They are the only players who have the scale and the relationships to turn it into a standard, which is good for everyone who sells overlays. More at the Lightspeed blog at http://lsvp.wordpress.com/2007/08/23/youtubes-entry-into-online-video-overlay-will-be-good-for-its-competitors/
jeremyliew on August 23rd, 2007 at 10:55 am - Permalink
Jeremy - Bingo!
Ty Graham on August 23rd, 2007 at 1:39 pm - Permalink
Just so you all we at VideoClix have prior art of Video Overlays Ads going back to 1999, your all welcome, Seriously :) …. Battle it out … whoever wins.. come talk to us…
Cheers
VCXJames on August 24th, 2007 at 2:52 am - Permalink
Why anyone would want to be tied to either platform is beyond me. Isn’t a white-label solution like Fliqz a better way to go?
techguy on August 24th, 2007 at 9:36 am - Permalink
[...] (which has seriously softened the language on its homepage since teasing YouTube for copying its ad formats last week) assures potential customers, “All content is reviewed by real people before any [...]
VideoEgg Overlaying Ads in Strange Places « NewTeeVee on August 29th, 2007 at 6:29 pm - Permalink
[...] ads, some people call them overlays, others call them bugs. Yes, these are the same units that VideoEgg got all huffy about when YouTube “copied” them last August (yesterday Sanchez called his company’s [...]
VideoEgg CEO: In-Video Ads a Tiny Market « NewTeeVee on April 1st, 2008 at 6:01 pm - Permalink
[...] and become a PR firm, because the company is definitely good at generating buzz. Whether it was declaring a turf war with YouTube over overlay ads, dropping video partners, or, like today, announcing new features to ad products [...]
VideoEgg: New Buzz for Old Hats « NewTeeVee on July 9th, 2008 at 4:46 pm - Permalink