NBC Direct: Don’t Bother
NBC launched its NBC Direct beta over the weekend. The service allows you to download NBC shows to your computer and view them for 48 hours, but compared with the rather elegant (though still limited) Hulu — which is part-owned by NBC — NBC Direct is an overly complicated mess.
First, it’s a separate download client that’s Windows-, Internet Explorer- and Windows Media Player-only. AOL dropped its Hi-Q service, which required a download, after low adoption. Rather than learn from history, NBC appears doomed to repeat it. It could just be the machine I was using, but the install process was long — it took more than 10 minutes just to get the software onto my computer.
NBC Direct offers only a few shows: 30 Rock, Bionic Woman, Friday Night Lights, Life and The Office. According to NBC, the shows available at any given time will expire seven days after being posted. So if you download one on the sixth day, you only get 24 hours to watch it before it disappears.
You can begin viewing a show while it’s still being downloaded, though when I tried to watch 30 Rock this way, it started, played through the opening credits and then abruptly went back to the beginning (where I had to sit through the pre-roll ad again).
|
I will say that the full-screen video looked fine, if a little grainy, with no stutters or stops or interruptions. The fast-forward and rewind buttons were finicky — working well sometimes, not working at all others.
The video “management” feature seems not even half-baked. Clicking on the icon drops you off back on the main web page where you can choose to subscribe. But all it says is “subscription change confirmed.”
And since this is NBC (GE), it’s chock-full of ads. There’s a pre-roll before the start of every program, then 15-second spots where there would normally be regular TV commercial breaks — which just reinforces the feeling that NBC is treating this as re-purposed TV. There are no embeds and no way to share. NBC says it will add more features, including cast and crew info, as well as commentaries and viewer reviews. It’s hard to muster a yawn.
In short, there is nothing user-friendly at all about this incarnation of NBC Direct and you should avoid it like the plague (or like season two of Heroes — which isn’t available on NBC Direct anyway). I could see it maybe being useful if I was flying somewhere and didn’t like any of films in my Netflix stack — maybe. But that’s hardly a reason to try it.
Sure, it’s in beta, but so was Hulu, and that service offers the same content plus a lot more, not to mention a much better user experience. Heck, NBC.com offers a better experience without any hassle. Right now the quality is not worth the effort, and with only NBC shows ever being available on here, I can’t imagine a time when that limited amount of content would be worth a separate download. Stick with streaming.
Recent
GigaOM Network
- Pencil Turns Firefox into a Drawing Tool [WebWorkerDaily]
- Independence Day Vid Pick: Muppets Salute America [NewTeeVee]
- Muppets Do Stars and Stripes Forever [NewTeeVee Station]
- Open Thread: Web Worker Independence [WebWorkerDaily]
- Structure 08 Recap: Yo Founders! There’s Gold in Them Clouds! [GigaOM]
Copyright 2001–2008 Giga Omni Media, Inc. All rights reserved. Powered by WordPress.com. Marketing consulting by ACS.
Any insight as to why NBC is rolling this out WITH Hulu?
Seems like they are just flailing around trying anything..or is that the strategy? :p
GearsofWar on November 11th, 2007 at 9:17 pm - Permalink
their strategy is half baked is what it is.
the experience of this service is the worst. after a 20+ minute install the shows would not even download. i have no desire to go back and try again. torrents are two clicks and it starts, done in 10 min. i could download and watch roughly 150 torrents with the same effort it required to watch zero shows on nbc direct.
buster on November 11th, 2007 at 9:47 pm - Permalink
[...] NBC.com fired up “NBC Direct” over the weekend - a new service that allows users to download full episodes of shows to your computer to watch anywhere. The service doesn’t work with my lowly MacBook Pro, so I can’t provide much of a review - but Chris Albrecht at NewTeeVee gave it a whirl and came back with a pretty negative review. [...]
NBC launches download service - Lost Remote TV Blog on November 11th, 2007 at 10:26 pm - Permalink
NBC fails at online video. Again.
Mike Abundo on November 11th, 2007 at 10:34 pm - Permalink
I tried it and I hate it compared to there streaming options at plain old NBC.com.
persch5 on November 12th, 2007 at 4:22 am - Permalink
So this is ad supported Peer Impact who had many of the same shows NBC Direct has and NBC could of just acquired that service with better video quality and faster progressive playback .Wurld Media Peer Impact’s parent company was sold to Roo for about 5 million earlier this year .
Matt Hendry on November 12th, 2007 at 4:34 am - Permalink
“Windows-, Internet Explorer- and Windows Media Player-only.”
What a shock, with that big “MS” hanging over NBC. Even General Electrc says “How high?” when the Redmond Beast says “Jump.”
Fred Tourette on November 12th, 2007 at 5:09 am - Permalink
lol…NBC Direct? This is laughable, if we want to watch NBC shows we can just go to Youtube or Cavenger.com
Mark on November 12th, 2007 at 6:06 am - Permalink
[...] Let’s take NBC Direct, the recently released video download service from NBC. The consensus appears to be that the service is constrained by technology requirements, limited in functionality, and imposes use rights that are so constrained as to make the service of little value to users. [...]
The Danger of Incrementalism : Venture Chronicles on November 12th, 2007 at 7:25 am - Permalink
[...] I mostly agree with NewTeeVee, which wrote today “NBC Direct: Don’t Bother”, I didn’t find the pre-roll ads at the start [...]
NBC Direct disappoints, adheres to network TV schedules | last100 on November 12th, 2007 at 1:19 pm - Permalink
[...] NBC DIRECT E’ UN DISASTRO [...]
N3TV NetTV: le news del 14.11.07 | N3TV on November 13th, 2007 at 4:14 pm - Permalink
[...] has launched its NBC Direct video download offering that is noteworthy only for the amount of scorn being heaped upon it from almost every reviewer out there. It appears to have made every single [...]
NBC Direct: Why Designing Consumer Entertainment Services By Committee Is A Dumb Idea | www.theirway.net on November 13th, 2007 at 6:05 pm - Permalink
[...] NTV Live Launchpad: MediaMelon Puts High-Res in the Browser NEWTEEVEE LIVE, SAN FRANCISCO — MediaMelon today announced the launch of a P2P video delivery network that allows viewers to watch high-res video within the browser — no downloadable client needed (are you listening, NBC?). [...]
NTV Live Launchpad: MediaMelon Puts High-Res in the Browser « NewTeeVee on November 14th, 2007 at 11:11 am - Permalink
[...] Source> [...]
November 15, 2007 | next media update on November 15th, 2007 at 9:17 am - Permalink
[...] has launched its NBC Direct video download offering that is noteworthy only for the amount of scorn being heaped upon it from almost every reviewer out there. It appears to have made every single [...]
Trying to Be like Bill Gates » Nokia to launch touch-screen version of S60 software (Reuters) on November 16th, 2007 at 8:24 am - Permalink
This piece of garbage also installs a process that runs on your PC even when not using NBC Direct. Its called MediaAgent and when I looked at it for awhile in the taskmanager it was using 60 megs of ram and would somtimes even eat CPU cycles without even being used.
Needless to say I deleted this garbage software right away
Joe on November 20th, 2007 at 4:56 am - Permalink
[...] sharp-eyed NTV reader tipped us off today about (yet another) problem with the NBC Direct download service. “Joe” wrote in [...]
NBC Direct Sucked…Your PC Resources « NewTeeVee on November 20th, 2007 at 11:00 pm - Permalink
[...] at home, you can now watch NBC content online at NBC.com, Hulu.com, Netflix, and if you’re glutton for punishment, through NBC [...]
Netflix to Show NBC Shows Online « NewTeeVee on November 29th, 2007 at 9:25 am - Permalink
[...] is reporting that the much-maligned NBC Direct service will incorporate Pando’s P2P technology to enable delivery of HD [...]
Viva La HD Revolution! « NewTeeVee on December 12th, 2007 at 1:56 pm - Permalink
[...] has launched its NBC Direct video download offering that is noteworthy only for the amount of scorn being heaped upon it from almost every reviewer out there. It appears to have made every single [...]
Bill Gates » Aruba Launches Counter-Offensive To Patent Suit on December 15th, 2007 at 3:44 am - Permalink
[...] is reporting that the much-maligned NBC Direct service will incorporate Pando’s P2P technology to enable delivery of HD [...]
Bandwidth Crisis » Blog Archive » Viva La HD Revolution! on February 28th, 2008 at 9:32 am - Permalink
[...] first version of NBC Direct, which came out way back in November, was a bear to install and ended up using obnoxious proportions of PC resources. Our advice then and now is to try Hulu [...]
NBC Direct, Take Two, Out for Testing « NewTeeVee on May 14th, 2008 at 11:01 pm - Permalink